Truth from the machine: artificial intelligence and the materialization of identity

When AI is seen as a source of truth and scientific knowledge, it may lend public legitimacy to harmful ideas about identity.

Access the Article

Critics now articulate their worries about the technologies, social practices and mythologies that comprise Artificial Intelligence (AI) in many domains. In this paper, we investigate the intersection of two domains of criticism: identity and scientific knowledge. On one hand, critics of AI in public policy emphasise its potential to discriminate on the basis of identity. On the other hand, critics of AI in scientific realms worry about how it may reorient or disorient research practices and the progression of scientific inquiry. We link the two sets of concerns—around identity and around knowledge—through a series of case studies. In our case studies, about autism and homosexuality, AI figures as part of scientific attempts to find, and fix, forms of identity. Our case studies are instructive: they show that when AI is deployed in scientific research about identity and personality, it can naturalise and reinforce biases. The identity-based and epistemic concerns about AI are not distinct. When AI is seen as a source of truth and scientific knowledge, it may lend public legitimacy to harmful ideas about identity.

Related Resources

What the 2026 Midterm Results Mean for Technology Policy

Commentary

What the 2026 Midterm Results Mean for Technology Policy

Drawing on local ballot measures and proposals from newly elected officials, this brief maps the technology policy themes of the 2026 US midterm elections.

More on this Issue

What the 2026 Midterm Results Mean for Technology Policy

Commentary

What the 2026 Midterm Results Mean for Technology Policy

Drawing on local ballot measures and proposals from newly elected officials, this brief maps the technology policy themes of the 2026 US midterm elections.

Field Report: How AI Is Being Used in the 2026 Midterms

Commentary

Field Report: How AI Is Being Used in the 2026 Midterms

Allen Lab Policy Fellow Hillary Lehr provides a late-October 2026 snapshot of the multiple ways that AI and the midterms are intersecting, including campaign use cases, policy issues, and voters’ use of LLMs.

California Writes Public Deliberation Into Law

Commentary

California Writes Public Deliberation Into Law

Engaged California is the nation’s first state-run deliberation program, and a new law aims to make it last.