Commentary  

Tech Policy that (Actually) Serves the People

Allen Lab for Democracy Renovation Fellow Ami Fields-Meyer lays out research questions for developing a new U.S. tech policy agenda that puts people first.

Credit: Unsplash, Rob Curran

At its best, digital technology makes life safer, healthier, and more empowering for people – but the products and practices of today’s largely self-governed tech industry too often limit people’s agency, undermine their economic stability, violate their rights and privacy, and do not meaningfully include them in decisions that will affect their own lives.

Research and reporting have shown that AI surveillance systems track workers’ every move, leading to workplace injuries. Corporate landlords and supermarket chains use AI and algorithms to artificially hike the costs of rent and groceries. Crypto tools, sometimes marketed as helping marginalized communities build wealth, are plagued by operational delays and hidden fees. Social media platforms surveil young people, selling their data and feeding them harmful content.

Despite these documented harms, the United States has never established rigorous governance of technology. Though public policy in a democratic society is forged in the clash and compromise between interests, American tech policy is often anchored by the narratives and norms of corporations that leverage well-financed political machinery to set the terms of debate. The result is a persistent gap in priorities, incentives, and power between a few large tech companies and the ordinary people who live with the real-world impact of their decisions.

Closing the Gap: A People’s Tech Movement

It is imperative that today’s policymakers mobilize around a new tech agenda that puts people first – a proactive vision for American society against which the nation’s leaders can measure the impact of each new advanced technology and make room for the American consumers, workers, and communities (“ordinary people”) in the innovation economy:

  • What does it look like to forge a U.S. tech policy that begins with the needs of ordinary people?
  • What flagship policies can return decision-making power over the role of technology in American society to ordinary people?
  • What big ideas can help awaken a deeper sense of urgency and immediacy for ordinary people on these critical issues of technology and power?
  • What are the most effective approaches to anchoring tech policy narratives in needs of the ordinary people, and allowing ordinary people to set the terms of policy debate?

These questions are the focus of my time as a Senior Fellow with the Allen Lab for Democracy Renovation at the Ash Center for Democratic Governance and Innovation. Through interviews, workshops, and other research, I am studying and developing policy interventions that can steer technological innovation toward agency, economic security, and opportunity for American consumers, workers, and communities. For the purposes of my research, I define these terms as follows:

  • Agency: protection of the civil and human rights of ordinary people and increases their power, voice, and choice in an the innovation economy
  • Economic Security: support for affordability, economic security, worker power and resilience for ordinary people in an innovation economy
  • Opportunity: ensuring that individuals, communities, small businesses, and new founders can compete meaningfully in an innovation economy, and that powerful technologies are leveraged to solve the problems of ordinary people

There are substantial gaps in Americans’ understanding of how data, digital technologies, and tech governance shape daily life. My research places a special emphasis on policy interventions that capture the public imagination, as well as messaging frames that effectively tie these challenges to issues that the American public is already concerned about and organized – such as healthcare, worker rights, and individual liberties. My work draws on the interdisciplinary expertise of academic research, policy design, political strategy, communications, and movement building.

I look forward to engaging with and learning from members of the Harvard community. If you are interested in this work, please contact me at afieldsmeyer@hks.harvard.edu.

 

Ami Fields-Meyer is Non-Resident Senior Fellow in the Allen Lab. He served in the White House from 2021 to 2024, including as senior policy advisor to Vice President Kamala Harris.

More from this Program

The Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley

Video

The Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley

The Ash Center hosted an online book talk with author Marietje Schaake and discussant Bruce Schneier on Schaake’s latest work, The Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley. The discussion was moderated by Danielle Allen, James Bryant Conant University Professor and Director of the Allen Lab for Democracy Renovation.

In The Tech Coup, Marietje Schaake explains how technology companies crept into nearly every corner of our lives and our governments. She takes us beyond the headlines to high-stakes meetings with human rights defenders, business leaders, computer scientists, and politicians to show how technologies have gone from being heralded as utopian to undermining the pillars of our democracies. To reverse this existential power imbalance, Schaake outlines solutions to empower elected officials and citizens alike. Democratic leaders can-and must-resist the influence of corporate lobbying and reinvent themselves as dynamic, flexible guardians of our digital world. Schaake offers a frightening look at our modern tech-obsessed world—and a clear-eyed view of how democracies can build a better future before it is too late.

The Role of AI in the 2024 Elections

Additional Resource

The Role of AI in the 2024 Elections

The year 2024 was dubbed “the largest election year in global history” with half the world’s population voting in national elections. Earlier this year, we hosted an event on AI and the 2024 Elections where scholars spoke about the potential influence of artificial intelligence on the election cycle– from misinformation to threats on election infrastructure. This webinar offered a reflection and exploration of the impacts of technology on the 2024 election landscape.

Political Economy of AI Essay Collection

Political Economy of AI Essay Collection

Earlier this year, the Allen Lab for Democracy Renovation hosted a convening on the Political Economy of AI. This collection of essays from leading scholars and experts raise critical questions surrounding power, governance, and democracy as they consider how technology can better serve the public interest.

More on this Issue

The Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley

Video

The Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley

The Ash Center hosted an online book talk with author Marietje Schaake and discussant Bruce Schneier on Schaake’s latest work, The Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley. The discussion was moderated by Danielle Allen, James Bryant Conant University Professor and Director of the Allen Lab for Democracy Renovation.

In The Tech Coup, Marietje Schaake explains how technology companies crept into nearly every corner of our lives and our governments. She takes us beyond the headlines to high-stakes meetings with human rights defenders, business leaders, computer scientists, and politicians to show how technologies have gone from being heralded as utopian to undermining the pillars of our democracies. To reverse this existential power imbalance, Schaake outlines solutions to empower elected officials and citizens alike. Democratic leaders can-and must-resist the influence of corporate lobbying and reinvent themselves as dynamic, flexible guardians of our digital world. Schaake offers a frightening look at our modern tech-obsessed world—and a clear-eyed view of how democracies can build a better future before it is too late.

The Role of AI in the 2024 Elections

Additional Resource

The Role of AI in the 2024 Elections

The year 2024 was dubbed “the largest election year in global history” with half the world’s population voting in national elections. Earlier this year, we hosted an event on AI and the 2024 Elections where scholars spoke about the potential influence of artificial intelligence on the election cycle– from misinformation to threats on election infrastructure. This webinar offered a reflection and exploration of the impacts of technology on the 2024 election landscape.